Web Letters: Empire or Republic?

Comment

By Robert Scheer

This article appeared in the June 30, 2008 edition of The Nation.

June 12, 2008

Write a Web letter about this article.

What's a Web Letter?

Web Letters are continuously published e-mails from real people, signed with their real names. No registration is required. Each article page on The Nation includes a Web Letters link.

Read the best Web Letters on this page.

We're committed to publishing your comments as they are received. We place a red star () on the best submissions and may edit your e-mail for length or content. Your e-mail address will not be published or shared with any third party without your consent.

If you prefer, you may submit a letter to the print edition only.

We look forward to hearing from you.

  • First, responding to the previous post: Have you noticed that the Navy is down to about 40 percent of its peak under Reagan? The Army shrank, too, which is why we have this misuse of the National Guard and Reserves!

    The biggest problem with funding on today's major new weapons systems is that they take up to fifteen years to actually produce. In WWII, such end-of-conflict items as the jet plane and the atomic bomb were both on the drawing boards by 1936, and actually used only nine years later.

    So, in voting against a new item, you have to be guessing at the geopolitical sitution and needs of at least twenty years or more in the future. Even the time that it takes to produce the next generation of older systems carries a risk with that kind of delay.

    Example: when the Kaiser was newly defeated, you would need to have something in progress to defeat Hitler and Tojo, who had yet to become significant.

    John D. Froelich

    Upper Darby, PA

    06/18/2008 @ 03:45am


  • The only beef I have with this article is the notion that tax receipts are a finite or fixed pool of funds. It's relatively easy to so restrict the flow of nutrients to a plant that you produce a bonsai tree many times smaller than its natural parents. The same process can be applied to an economy, and by the same restrictive procedures drastiacally reduce the size of the result. But which one would you want to harvest from (which is, analogically speaking, what taxation represents)?

    The idea that there are a fixed, finite set of resources in the world is a very perniciously dangerous--and totally wrong--conception. Resources are not things that occur absent any human presence. Without a man to devise an engine that burns petrol, crude oil is simply a mildly interesting form of mud. Without a man to devise a nuclear power plant, uranium is just another rock. Thus, nothing becomes a resource without the presence, and liberated ingenuity, of man.

    Therefore, the most precious resource on this benighted planet is the mind of man. Ironically, it is the strangulation of this resource, and its pernicious consequences, that your article addresses. Please do not concede ground to our ideological enemies by conceding to their perverse premise that any resource is fixed and finite--and therefore must be fought over.

    Denver Fletcher

    Freiburg, Germany

    06/16/2008 @ 9:39pm


  • When the Soviet Union collapsed we were promised significant cuts in military spending. Thanks to Bill Clinton and Dubya, nothing happened. Why should it happen now? Don't believe it.

    As Bertolt Brecht wrote in <>The Three-Penny Opera, the army is always re-forming (not reforming).

    Norman Ravitch

    Savannah, GA

    06/13/2008 @ 6:12pm


Advertisement
Advertisement

Blogs

» State of Change

Obama Anoints Kaine, Praises (And Snubs?) Dean | Obama and Kaine signal they'll continue the fifty-state strategy, but why wasn't Dean in the building?
Ari Berman
Posted at 5:17 PM ET

» Altercation

Altercation 3.0 | Altercation takes up residence today at The Nation. In this incarnation, expect more music and movies and maybe a little less politics. But first, a word about Cass Sunstein.
Eric Alterman
Posted at 3:45 PM ET

» Editor's Cut

Obama Must Get Afghanistan Right | If he doesn't, the US will be stuck in another military catastrophe.
Katrina vanden Heuvel

» Capitolism

ET Come Home | Tom Friedman testifies on Capitol Hill on green technology
Christopher Hayes

» The Beat

Feingold's Outline for a Constitutional Presidency | In a letter to Obama, Constitution subcommittee chair seeks a commitment to end executive excess.
John Nichols

» The Dreyfuss Report

Panetta? Ummmmm... Well..... | Could Obama have made a weirder choice for CIA director? Here's why Panetta is doomed.
Robert Dreyfuss

» Act Now!

Allow Media into Gaza | Israel is encouraging abuses by preventing foreign journalists from entering the Gaza Strip.
Peter Rothberg

» The Notion

Hard Times Without Studs | One of Terkel’s former book editors considers a Studs-less world.
Tom Engelhardt

» And Another Thing

Bill Ayers Whitewashes History, Again | The Weathermen were not just a bunch of idealistic young people.
Katha Pollitt